Navajo Nation president urges residents not to use EPA form for claims

Joshua Kellogg
The Daily Times

SHIPROCK — Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye has warned tribal residents to avoid using the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's form for claims of damage or injury as a result of the Gold King Mine spill.

In the president's Wednesday directive Navajo Nation Attorney General Ethel Branch advised that the federal form "contains offending language that will waive future claims for individuals that sign the form and preclude our people from seeking full compensation for injuries suffered from the spill."

The memorandum directs all of the tribe's divisions to stop promoting the form unless authorized to do so by the president's office.

In a meeting Wednesday at the Shiprock Chapter house, Robert Joe, the acting chief of staff for the Office of the President and Vice President, said the president's office does not support residents filling out EPA Standard Form No. 95. The form concerns damages to property from the release last week of toxic mine waste into the Animas and San Juan rivers from Gold King Mine north of Silverton, Colo.

"We do not support it. I know the president does not support that. The EPA created the situation, they should be accountable and held responsible," Joe said in an interview after the meeting.

An EPA official could not be reached for comment late Wednesday night.

San Juan County Executive Officer Kim Carpenter spoke during Wednesday's meeting at the Shiprock Chapter house and encouraged people to seek assistance after the spill. In an interview Wednesday evening after the meeting, he said he did not agree with President Begaye's directive.

"When you mix politics with something like this, it doesn't mix," he said. "I'm interested in taking care of the people."

Navajo Nation Council Speaker LoRenzo Bates does not have a position on whether residents should fill out the form, said his legislative staff assistant, Pete Ken Atcitty, during the Shiprock meeting.

"I just want to make that clear that the speaker's office and Navajo Nation Council isn't pushing anything upon any Navajo constituents, we just want to give you as much information as we can," Atcitty said.

In a statement issued Wednesday evening, Bates said Diné citizens deserve to be compensated to the fullest extent, and the EPA must be held accountable for its negligence.

He encouraged the public to read the form thoroughly and seek further consultation to make an informed decision.

New Mexico Attorney General Hector Balderas said Wednesday afternoon that he wanted Navajo residents to seek proper legal counsel in their dispute with the EPA.

"I don't think anyone has talked about deploying proper legal resources to these rural communities," Balderas said, adding that it should be done.

He said that as attorney general, he is limited in his ability to provide legal advice.

Reporters Noel Lynn Smith and Steve Garrison contributed to the story.

Joshua Kellogg covers education for The Daily Times. He can be reached at 505-564-4627 and Follow him @jkelloggdt on Twitter.