Ex-police evidence tech sentenced to probation

If Ashley Goodvoyce violates probation, she faces up to seven and a half years in prison

Steve Garrison
  • Ashley Goodvoyce, a former Farmington police evidence technician, has been sentenced to probation.
  • The 28-year-old pleaded guilty in February to stealing drugs and cash from the police evidence room.
  • She faced prison time, but the judge said testimony from the police chief swayed him to probation.
  • Goodvoyce's arrest led officials to implement new security measures and change department policies.
Ashley Goodvoyce

FARMINGTON — Former Farmington police evidence technician Ashley Goodvoyce was sentenced today to probation for her October 2014 conviction in the theft of drugs and cash from the police department's evidence room.

She was initially sentenced to seven and a half years in prison, but that was suspended and Goodvoyce will instead serve five years of probation.

Judge John Dean further ordered Goodvoyce to pay $45,000 in fines and write letters of apology to her former coworkers, police officials and the San Juan County District Attorney's Office.

If Goodvoyce violates the terms of her probation, she will face up to seven and a half years in prison.

"There will be zero tolerance," Dean said.

Goodvoyce faced up to 15 years in prison after she pleaded guilty Feb. 3 to embezzlement, forgery, five counts of tampering with public records and two counts of possession of a controlled substance.

Dean said he initially believed Goodvoyce should be sentenced to prison, but he was convinced to sentence her to probation after hearing testimony from Farmington police Chief Steve Hebbe.

Famington Police Chief Steve Hebbe walks out of the courtroom on Thursday after a sentencing hearing for Ashley Goodvoyce at the Aztec District Court.

Goodvoyce did not address the judge and declined to answer questions after the hearing. Her attorney, Arlon Stoker, pointed out that Goodvoyce cooperated fully with the department's investigation and had no prior criminal record.

Hebbe told the judge Goodvoyce was a trusted and well-liked employee whose actions tarnished the department's reputation and cost taxpayers ten of thousands of dollars.

However, he said, he did not want Dean to "throw the book" at the 28-year-old woman.

"I hope she has gotten a grip on what caused her to do these things, and I hope she can get her life back on track," Hebbe said.

Former Farmington Police Department evidence technician Ashley Goodvoyce listens on Thursday at her sentencing hearing at the Aztec District Court. Goodvoyce was sentenced to five years of probation.

Farmington police officials discovered on Oct. 14, 2014, that thousands of dollars and hundreds of prescription pain pills were missing from the department's evidence room, leading to Goodvoyce's arrest and a full audit of sensitive items held by the department.

Officials changed department policies after the thefts and implemented new security measures, including motion-activated cameras and key-less entry systems.

Hebbe was recognized last year by the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies for his transparent response to the discovery.

Officials initially feared the thefts would cause numerous criminal cases to be dismissed due to a broken chain of custody. But at Thursday's hearing, Hebbe said fewer than a dozen cases were affected.

Prosecutor Christopher Spinner told Dean on Thursday that the evidence tampering did not lead to any cases being dismissed nor to any defendants being offered plea deals.

Steve Garrison covers crime and courts for The Daily Times. He can be reached at 505-564-4644. 

Judge John Dean hands down the sentence for Ashley Goodvoyce on Thursday at Aztec District Court. The former Farmington police evidence technician was sentenced to five years of probation for stealing cash and drugs from the police department's evidence room.