Roth shot a 66 on Tuesday, the final day of the three-day tournament. The score got him to 4-under for the tournament, good for second place in the tournament at inn of the Mountain Gods Championship Golf Course in Mescalero.
David Muttitt ran away from the field, posting an 8-under to win.
Roth finished one-stroke ahead of third place finisher Daniel Koesters.
Miguel Bautista was the only other golfer at par or better for the tournament, shooting an even 213.
Roth took home $2,200 for the second-place finish.