Click photo to enlarge
Camille Cruz's purple violin caused a stir at her middle school when her teacher asked that she rent a standard violin so she could fit in with the class.
Camille Cruz’s purple violin caused a stir at her middle school when her teacher asked that she rent a standard violin so she could fit in with the
Camille Cruz's purple violin caused a stir at her middle school when her teacher asked that she rent a standard violin so she could fit in with the class. (Augusta Liddic/The Daily Times)
FARMINGTON — When it comes to fiddling around, the classic wooden body seems to be preferred in the orchestra class at Farmington's Tibbetts Middle School.

Camille Cruz was told this week that her purple violin was not suitable for the orchestra class and the sixth-grader would have to rent one of the district's violins that is a more traditional color for $30, Sherry Lopez, the 11-year-old's mother, said.

Lopez said the teacher, Monica Leaming, cited a difference in tone and distraction as the reason for changing instruments.

Lopez became agitated when her daughter informed her that she would need to find another violin for the class. She has called the school principal and district officials lobbying for equal treatment for violins of all colors.

"It's like telling Axl Rose he has to use some guitar from Kmart," Lopez said. "He doesn't want to use that. He wants to use his own guitar."

Calls left at Tibbetts Middle School on Friday were not returned.

Cruz said she was allowed to use her purple violin in class on Friday. She was not certain if her teacher changed her mind about the violin or if she will have to find another violin to be in the orchestra.

School district officials were notified of the tension in the Tibbitts' orchestra on Friday, Chris Pash, the director of secondary curriculum and instruction for Farmington schools, said.

He was confident the matter will be resolved promptly.


Advertisement

"We'll work something out that's going to be agreeable to both sides," he said. "We don't want to keep anybody out of orchestra."

Cruz said the violin was a gift from her grandmother two years ago.

Her grandmother purchased a purple violin because purple is Cruz's favorite color.

Cruz is a beginner at the instrument. Her repertoire of songs consists of "Mary Had a Little Lamb" and "Good King Wenceslas" but she's hoping to learn more songs in orchestra class.

Cruz said her classmates were not distracted by the color of her violin.

"They said 'Oh, that's so cool. I wish we all had purple violins'," Cruz said.

Cruz and her mother recently moved to Farmington and Cruz transferred to Tibbetts on Tuesday.

Cruz said she was excited to resolve the issue with her violin and improve his musical skills.

"I feel strangely about it," she said of the controversy her violin caused. "I hope I can play my own violin and this can all be over with."